Police Brutality & Mental Health Crisis

I am feeling frustrated and angry right now, abuse of power within the police force is hardly a new concept – people in positions of authority are known for becoming bullies, they get a taste of that power that comes with control and they become frightened of losing it so they ‘command respect’ by exploiting those weaker than themselves in an effort to appear bigger and better in hope of holding onto their position a little longer.

What they don’t realise is that when they act this way nobody respects them anymore, nobody looks up to them, instead they fear them, and respect and fear are two very different things.

Image from “The Age” article referenced below

I read an article about members of The Victorian Police mistreating a man in a Mental Health Crisis in The Age today, I don’t know if Victorian Police are actually worse than the rest of the country’s police force or if they just get more press for their indiscretions but again they made the papers for their actions and no wonder, watching the footage below I was simply disgusted.


And people wonder why people with mental illness are afraid to disclose suicidal ideation, why they are afraid of authority and afraid to ask for help. This isn’t “help”.

Nobody deserves to be treated that way. As this article discusses, Police officers themselves are having their own mental health issues minimised or blown off completely by their colleagues and commanding officers, encouraged to just “suck it up”, suicide rates among police officers are increasing and it’s no wonder that this is impacting their treatment of civilians.

In the middle of a mental health crisis you may be feeling many things, but from my own experiences and that of the people I speak to everyday with mental illness, fear is the biggest common denominator.

During my own stays in psychiatric units I saw plenty of people in various states of crisis brought in by police, some were psychotic and completely out of control, lashing out violently at anything and everything around them, others were also psychotic but quiet and subdued, some were depressed and had been threatening self-harm or suicide but had not at all ‘lost touch with reality’. All were handcuffed.

When you are in a heightened state and frightened, nothing is going to make you feel even more like killing or defending yourself than being apprehended in the manner exhibited in that footage by those very people that are supposed to be placed in the community to “help” you.

If I am unwell and particularly if I have become paranoid, then a group of police officers swooping into my home in that manner is just going to confirm my deepest fears, show me I really cannot trust anyone except myself and it’s far more likely to cause me to lash out in a way I never would normally.

Seriously, what are they thinking? Is it purely fear and lack of understanding about mental illness? Is it because someone who is in a MH crisis is considered unpredictable so police adopt the brute force approach in an attempt to defend themselves before a threat is even made?

Perhaps if I was in a crisis and approached thoughtfully and calmly by someone who was not wielding handcuffs, perhaps if I were to be engaged in conversation, listened to, my right to be treated as a human being validated then perhaps I would be less frightened, less likely to act impulsively or violently, more likely to agree to treatment. If I am suicidal then being swarmed on by police is going to make that even worse, particularly if it is in public – the embarrassment alone would destroy any remaining will for life. It doesn’t exactly encourage you to ask for help!

Even in a state of psychosis, simply being spoken to in a calm manner changes the perception of danger for the person who is unwell and if they are not feeling threatened then they have no reason to react violently.

Personally, I have thankfully never been apprehended by the police although I have certainly been threatened with it by mental health workers, during a Bipolar Manic Episode once I was told that if I didn’t sleep that night police officers would be sent to my home, arrest me, handcuff me and throw me in the back of a van and take me to hospital against my will.

(This threat actually led to an accidental overdose and subsequent involuntary hospitalisation, but that’s another story…)

So, what exactly are the procedures in place in Australia when someone is in a mental health crisis and considered to be in “immediate danger”?

In a simple google search I am unable to find the exact information but it seems that once a person has been deemed as a threat to themselves or others then the police can be contacted to apprehend them (by it seems whatever means necessary) and take them to the hospital along with an ambulance for a psychiatric assessment. I will ask a police officer I know for more information about exactly what is expected from them in these situations and what training they have in this area and let you guys know what I find out.

So how can we change things?

Well I imagine that as with most deficits in areas of a social nature that this is a federal and state budget issue, however other countries seem to be able to implement positive changes in these areas which I imagine could only save the departments money in the long run, so it is possible. I read this article: https://www.indystar.com/story/news/crime/2017/07/27/opioid-epidemic-mental-illness-crushing-indianapolis-citys-new-approach/493499001/ which is about a mental health crisis intervention team that has been formed in Indianapolis to help combat the opioid problem they are facing.

The team consists of a police officer, a paramedic and a clinician who are all specifically trained in Mental Health and crisis care, they go out as first responders and it is working really well, there is no reason why this style of approach cannot be used in Australia and for broad spectrum mental health crisis.

What is your take on this approach?

How do you feel about the way the police handle mental health crisis where you live?


14 Comments on “Police Brutality & Mental Health Crisis

  1. one time i was arrested under the mental health act, and had to be seen by a doctor at the police station and evaluated before being taken to hospital. lucky though the police were really good, kind, compassionate and very caring. xo

    Liked by 1 person

  2. In the city where I live we’ve got a partnership between the police and the health authority that involves a plainclothes police officer and mental health nurse responding to mental health calls in an unmarked police car. It works quite well, but it would be nice to see it expanded. In my Canadian province, our Mental Health Act has a section that allows police to apprehend someone and take them to hospital to be assessed by a doctor. The person has to be obviously suffering from acute mental illness (the police aren’t expected to medically assess someone so it has to be obvious) and present a clear risk of harm to themselves or others. If a doctor in the community has assessed a patient and completed a Mental Health Act certificate to commit them to hospital, but then the patient takes off, the police can be asked to locate the person and take them to hospital based on that Mental Health Act certificate. I’ve actually had mostly positive experiences dealing with police while working as a nurse, but that’s probably because I worked in an inner city area with a high concentration of mental illness and addiction, so the cops were pretty familiar with those kinds of issues.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. I honestly don’t know how is the French Police dealing with such cases. I’ve been living in France for only four years and deep in the countryside, totally isolated. As far as the Swiss police, from what I have been told, the handled mental crises very well and respectfully.
    As I mentioned once or twice, I have read the latest European Human Right Convention a few times and we’re not mentioned as a specific group as others are, anywhere. We need to level the legal playing field in order to have our legal rights applied across the board. I am convinced that we won’t be able to achieve anything until we are acknowledged legally. This how previous causes went about it.

    Liked by 1 person

    • It’s good that you haven’t had to find out for yourself and I’m glad to hear that the Swiss police handle things professionally. I hope that things improve from a legal standpoint – I guess mental illness varies so much with each individual, some people in crisis will have no way of being able to contribute to their care while others will be quite capable of having input. I suppose that is where having a family member or a friend acting as an advocate helps.

      Liked by 1 person

    • I guess I can only comment about what I have seen in the footage and I would love to hear the policeman side of the story too but I doubt I ever will. From my own experiences when frightened in the middle of a mental health crisis, people abusing their power and acting cruelly based on their own thoughts or emotions rather than acting professionally to the existing threat level of the situation is far more likely to just make things worse. Mistreating and then laughing at someone in distress like that when you have a duty of care to them is inexcusable.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. We make no money off of this Podcast (now up to 30,000 listeners). It is dedicated to bring Police and Society closer together. We do two shows each week hosted by two former cops and deal with hot button issues to educate society. I hope you will listen. We have the best intentions! http://www.policingblackandwhite.wordpress.com . We cover all these details: guns, crimes, concealment, 2nd amendment, different types or firearms, and we even go to the range with a taster, shotgun, rifle, pistol, and OC spray, and use them on volunteers to show what they can and can’t do. We listen to citizens and they teach us too!

    Liked by 1 person

  5. I have no desire to be closer together with murders. They killed my husband and used my mental disability and their deceit and absolute bullying and brutality to cover up what they did. I tell my grandchildren never to go near a police officer, if they ask questions say nothing till I am called and I don’t care how old they are. They are deceitful, cowardly, murders. They kill people, innocent people, and walk away like the sociopaths that they are.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Pingback: Police Brutality & Mental Health Crisis – JOURNEY FOR JUSTICE

Leave a Reply to c2justice Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: